Choosing the Best Payroll Service: OnPay vs Gusto – An In-depth Comparison

In the realm of payroll and HR software solutions, OnPay and Gusto are two popular options that provide comprehensive services for small businesses. Both platforms offer a range of features designed to simplify and streamline payroll processes, benefits administration, and other essential HR tasks. However, there are some key differences between the two that can influence which platform is the best fit for your business.

OnPay: Affordable and Robust

For small business owners looking for an affordable yet comprehensive payroll and HR solution, OnPay is worth considering. With OnPay, you get access to a wide range of features typically found in more expensive platforms, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious entrepreneurs.

One of the standout features of OnPay is its affordability. The platform offers transparent pricing with a simple monthly fee that includes unlimited pay runs, tax filings, and other essential payroll functions. This predictability makes it easier to budget and plan your expenses.

Furthermore, OnPay provides robust reporting capabilities, allowing you to track employee hours, generate detailed payroll reports, and gain valuable insights into your workforce. This feature can help you make data-driven decisions and effectively manage your staff.

Gusto: User-Friendly and Comprehensive

Gusto, on the other hand, is known for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive HR features. It offers an intuitive platform that simplifies payroll processing and automates various HR tasks, providing a seamless experience for small business owners.

One of Gusto’s notable strengths is its emphasis on compliance. The platform ensures that your business stays up to date with ever-changing tax regulations, minimizing the risk of errors and penalties. Gusto also handles all necessary payroll tax filings and payments on your behalf, saving you time and reducing administrative burden.

Additionally, Gusto offers a range of HR services, including onboarding, benefits administration, and employee self-service tools. These features enable you to manage your workforce more effectively and enhance employee engagement.

Choosing the Right Solution for Your Business

When deciding between OnPay and Gusto, it’s crucial to assess your business’s specific needs and priorities. Here are some factors to consider:

      • Pricing: Evaluate the cost-effectiveness of each platform and determine which aligns with your budget.
      • Features: Consider the specific payroll and HR functions that are essential for your business’s operations.
      • User Experience: Assess the ease of use and intuitiveness of each platform, as this can impact your efficiency and productivity.
      • Scalability: Think about the future growth of your business and whether the platform can accommodate your needs over time.
See also  2021 Reviews of Small Business Stripe Payments: A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Best Financial Solution for Your Company

Ultimately, both OnPay and Gusto offer reliable payroll and HR solutions for small businesses. While OnPay may be more appealing for its affordability and robust reporting capabilities, Gusto stands out for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive HR services. By carefully considering your business’s requirements, you can determine which platform best suits your needs.

In conclusion, when comparing OnPay vs. Gusto, both platforms have their strengths and cater to different business needs. It is essential to weigh factors such as pricing, features, user experience, and scalability to make an informed decision.

Comparing OnPay and Gusto: Which Payroll Service is Right for Your Business?

When it comes to choosing a payroll service for your business, two popular options are OnPay and Gusto. Both platforms offer a range of features and benefits, but there are key differences to consider.

Cost: OnPay has a straightforward pricing structure, charging a base fee plus a per-employee fee. Gusto, on the other hand, offers three pricing tiers with different features at each level. Consider your business size and needs to determine which pricing model aligns best with your budget.

Features: Both OnPay and Gusto offer core payroll features such as automated tax calculations, direct deposit, and employee self-service. However, Gusto goes beyond payroll by offering additional HR features like onboarding, compliance support, and access to HR experts. Review your business requirements to prioritize the features that matter most to you.

User Experience: OnPay is known for its user-friendly interface and easy setup process. They provide excellent customer support, including personalized help from a dedicated payroll expert. Gusto also offers a user-friendly platform with a modern design and intuitive navigation. Consider which platform aligns better with your team’s technical skills and preferences.

Add-Ons and Integrations: Both services offer integrations with popular accounting software, time tracking tools, and retirement plans. Additionally, Gusto provides integrations with a range of third-party apps to enhance functionality. Evaluate which add-ons and integrations are essential for your business operations.

In conclusion, choosing between OnPay and Gusto depends on your specific business needs, preferences, and budget. Consider factors such as pricing, features, user experience, and available integrations to make an informed decision.

Related questions

Which payroll management software, OnPay or Gusto, offers better features for small businesses in terms of cost efficiency and ease of use?

OnPay and Gusto are both popular payroll management software options for small businesses, but they have slightly different features and pricing structures.

See also  Starting an LLC in Texas: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners


  • Cost efficiency: OnPay offers a straightforward pricing model, charging a base fee per month plus an additional fee per employee. This can be cost-effective for small businesses with a limited number of employees.
  • Ease of use: OnPay is known for its user-friendly interface and intuitive navigation, making it easy for users to manage their payroll without extensive training or technical expertise.
  • Features: OnPay provides essential payroll features such as automatic tax calculations, direct deposit, and payroll tax filing. It also integrates with popular accounting software such as QuickBooks and Xero.


  • Cost efficiency: Gusto’s pricing structure is also based on a per-month fee per employee but may offer additional features and services at higher price tiers. This may be a better fit for businesses that need more advanced HR and benefits features.
  • Ease of use: Gusto is known for its modern and user-friendly interface, providing an intuitive experience for users. They offer a guided setup process and provide access to online resources for support.
  • Features: Gusto not only offers basic payroll functions but also includes features like benefits administration, time tracking, and employee onboarding. It has integrations with various accounting software and third-party apps.

Ultimately, the choice between OnPay and Gusto depends on the specific needs and preferences of the small business. Both options offer cost-efficient solutions with user-friendly interfaces, so businesses should consider their desired features, scalability, and budget when making a decision.

How do OnPay and Gusto compare in terms of their ability to handle complex payroll processes, such as multiple pay rates, overtime calculations, and tax filings?

OnPay and Gusto are both popular payroll service providers that offer various features to handle complex payroll processes.

OnPay is known for its flexibility in handling complex payroll needs. It allows businesses to set up multiple pay rates easily, including hourly, salaried, and contracted rates. This makes it suitable for businesses with diverse payment structures. OnPay also has comprehensive overtime calculation capabilities, including customizable rules for overtime calculations based on federal, state, or company policies. Additionally, OnPay provides automatic tax filings and payments, ensuring compliance with tax regulations. They take care of all payroll-related tax calculations, filings, and payments, saving businesses time and effort.

Gusto is another popular payroll software that offers robust features for managing complex payroll processes. Gusto allows businesses to set up multiple pay rates efficiently, making it easy to handle different wage structures. It also has built-in overtime calculations based on federal and state labor laws. Gusto offers automatic tax filings and payments, similar to OnPay, simplifying the payroll tax process for businesses. It ensures accurate tax calculations and handles filings on behalf of businesses, reducing the chance of errors and penalties.

See also  Top Reviews of Small Business National Funding: Unveiling the Best Business Loan Options

In terms of handling complex payroll processes such as multiple pay rates, overtime calculations, and tax filings, both OnPay and Gusto offer reliable solutions. Both platforms have user-friendly interfaces and provide excellent customer support to assist businesses with any payroll-related questions or issues.

Ultimately, the choice between OnPay and Gusto depends on the specific needs and preferences of the business. It is recommended to evaluate their additional features, pricing structures, and overall user experience before making a decision.

What are the key differences between OnPay and Gusto in terms of customer support, user interface, and integration capabilities with other financial systems?

OnPay and Gusto are both popular payroll software providers for small businesses in the United States. While they offer similar features, there are some key differences to consider when it comes to customer support, user interface, and integration capabilities with other financial systems.

Customer Support: Both OnPay and Gusto provide reliable customer support options. OnPay offers phone and email support during business hours, with live chat available on their website. Gusto also offers phone and email support, but they go a step further by offering 24/7 support and an online help center with extensive resources.

User Interface: OnPay and Gusto have user-friendly interfaces, but there are some differences in their design and navigation. OnPay has a straightforward and clean interface, making it easy for users to navigate through different features. Gusto, on the other hand, has a more modern and visually appealing interface with intuitive navigation menus.

Integration Capabilities: When it comes to integration capabilities, both OnPay and Gusto offer seamless integrations with popular accounting software such as QuickBooks and Xero. However, Gusto provides a wider range of integrations with other financial systems, such as time tracking, expense management, and benefits administration platforms. This allows users to streamline their overall financial management processes.

In conclusion, both OnPay and Gusto are reputable payroll software providers with their own strengths. OnPay offers reliable customer support and a straightforward user interface, while Gusto stands out with its extensive integration capabilities and 24/7 support. Choosing between the two would depend on the specific needs and priorities of your small business.

Disclaimer: The information provided here is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered as professional financial advice. Always seek the advice of a qualified expert or conduct thorough research with official sources before making any financial decisions.


Table of contents

Discover financial empowerment on, your guide through the world of credit, loans, insurance, and investment with straightforward, expert advice.

Recent articles